Saturday, September 29, 2012

Compare & Contrast : Seurat & Signac


Two of the paintings I found to be most interesting during my visit to The Metropolitan Museum of Art were Georges Seurat’s Study for A Sunday on La Grande Jatte and Paul Signac’s Notre-Dame-de-la-Garde (La Bonne-Mere), Marseilles. Both immediately caught my eye with their dynamic compositions and strong usage of color.  Also, I was excited to see work by Seurat because he was an artist that we had briefly discussed in class. 
Study for A Sunday on La Grande Jatte is exactly what it sounds like.  It is a preliminary oil painting describing the overall composition for A Sunday Afternoon on the Island of La Grande Jatte. The most noticeable difference between this study and the complete painting is the way in which Seurat applied the paint to the canvas.  In the preliminary study the colors come together by way of short, patchy brush strokes.  While in the final work of art, the paint was applied in a more purposeful and systematic manner. His style of painting has come to be known as Pointillism or Divisionism.  It involves the placement of small touches of individual colors in close proximity to each other.  This allows the colors to blend in the eye of the spectator, giving the painting a brilliant and harmonious unification.
In comparison to Seurat, Signac delved even deeper into the methodology of Divisionism.  He focused on the division of light into components of pure color, arranging rectangular brushstrokes into mosaic-like patterns.  Also, due to the fact that he employed the use of unmixed pigments, the color of this painting is more luminous and vibrant that those of Seurat. 
Other than the style in which they were painted, what the two paintings have in common is quite obvious.  They share a fairly similar subject matter with both depicting calm, relaxing scenes near bodies of water.  Also, in areas, they demonstrate a shift in color from dark to light, creating depth and clear points of focus.

Study for A Sunday on La Grande Jatte, 1884
Georges Seurat
Oil on canvas
Notre-Dame-de-la-Garde (La Bonne-Mere), Marseilles, 1905-6Paul Signac
Oil on canvas

1 comment:

  1. Ivana:
    This is excellent critical commentary! I really feel you should take as many art history classes as you can, and maybe be a curatorial studies minor. You have a natural gift for research and are also very perceptive...I am really impressed, an so glad you recalled having mentioned Seurat in the studio a few weeks back in relation to pointillism!

    ReplyDelete